Practically everyone on the web has, at some point in our browsing career, lost a login name or it’s password, requiring us to put ourselves through the terrifying automated reset-or-retrieval process. Usually this is about as difficult as clicking a link, waiting four seconds, and checking our inbox. We bang our heads against our keyboards as we cry out
“Why do I need a separate identity for every, single, site?!!“
[OpenID enters dramatically from stage left]
On Wednesday, Brady Forrest wrote:
“OpenID is an identity system that allows you to have one username and one password for multiple sites. Your username is an URL. The password is whatever you choose (and like all passwords you should keep it secret).”
“Identity is one of the last pieces of the Web 2.0 puzzle to become decentralized and fully owned by the user. Up till now we’ve had to rely on sites to control our identity; now with personal sites (mostly blogs) becoming common there is finally a mechanism for us to take our identities into our own hands.”
Hasn’t our online identity been in our own hands since we started using email? Some sites are trusting enough to believe us when we say we’re $celebrityOfWeek, while others send a verification email just to be sure. I don’t understand why we need another layer of identity at all. What happens when I forget my OpenID password? Does the service provider email it to me?
“Lately there have been a plethora of OpenID services launching. All users of SixApart’s Vox and LiveJournal users automatically have OpenIDs. If you want to use a hosted service JanRain’s MyOpenID just launched”
I thought OpenID was conceived to solve the “too many identities” problem. It seems to me this is just making a mess of a mess. Let’s suppose I’m writing a comment on your OpenID-enabled blog. Do I sign in with my Vox account, my Livejournal, or another? Half of your users may be internet geeks with this problem, while the other half has no idea what an OpenID is or where to get one.
This week I’m faced with deciding upon identity systems for several forthcoming web applications. I’d be thrilled if some enlightened commenter could show me that I’m making a mistake, but it looks like I’ll be sticking with my old friend, email, for now.
Filed by Logan at December 22nd, 2006 under
Life,
Design |
4 comments